Don’t follow TripAdvisor wearing a blindfold

Published on : Saturday, May 7, 2016

online hotel bookingWhile choosing a hotel we mostly look through TripAdvisor hoping to get authentic feedbacks and generally make online bookings based of this. Yes, TripAdvisor is one of the most authentic sources which provide you with reviews served by guests who share their experiences.



The site claims that it has a critical metric for many hotels. Based on traveler feedback, a property’s ranking on the Popularity Index reflects how it compares to other hotels within a geographic area. TripAdvisor says that the Popularity Index algorithm is based on three key ingredients: the quality, quantity, and recency of reviews. It also claims its Insights blog take content integrity very seriously and screen every review. If you are caught breaking the guidelines, it can take a big hit on your popularity ranking.



TripAdvisor receives 70 reviews every minute with more than 100 million reviews in a day. The site gets 230 million online visitors each month and lists nearly three million hotels, restaurants and other attractions, along with eight million accompanying photographs. Chances of fake misleading reviews can be very high. There is not much that these sites can do to protect themselves from fraudulent comment.




The site does not disclose all the elements of its popularity index algorithm. It doesn’t reveals which is more important, a property’s average review score or total number of reviews?  The scoring system is like this 1 extra point on average review score will, on average, increase Popularity Index rank by 321 places. 1 extra review will increase Popularity Index rank 1.5 places.




So when a hotel calculates its ranking on TripAdvisor, The weights of a property’s average review score is 20,000 times more than its total number of reviews. So even if the score stayed same on average review and you increase the volume or quantity it would take 2, 1400 reviews to increase your rank by the same amount as one average review point.




Average review of the property counts 85% of the total popularity index ranking, total number of review counts 6% on the property ranking and 9% goes unexplained. So the key to staying at the top of the popularity index of TripAdvisor it is important to get greater quantity of recent reviews to dominate your competition. TripAdvisor says “The key to building a successful business and a higher popularity ranking is stellar hospitality and paying attention to your customers’ needs. Encourage customers to write reviews, learn from them and watch your hard work pay off.”



This system of rating leaves hoteliers under immense pressure as one negative review leaves hoteliers completely petrified. They can do most anything to get a good review. The reviews may not always be connected to service but at times very personal but greatly harming the hotel’s ranking on the site.



Hoteliers are finding this ranking pattern to be somewhat frustrating and often get back to TripAdvisor begging them to remove their hotel from the site as it is more harming than improving their business. There are many fake reviews that badly slump their ranking and popularity.



There are instances that prove the discrepancy in rating. Where a hotel had 85 reviews 73 excellent 10 very good and 2 good reviews, they had been listed on TripAdvisor for 9 years and were ranked 6th out of 47 hotels. The hotel listed 1st only had 9 reviews, 7 excellent and 2 very good and had only been listed on TripAdvisor for just over a year, BOTH hotels had very recent reviews. So how does this hotel rating site explain this factor?



There could be a possibility that the site maybe accepting payment for improving ranking of hotels. If you look up any city on TripAdvisor, and check the rankings, it never makes sense when you look at the review details, BUT it is as clear as daylight that nearly all the highest ranking listings are also “Paid Listings”.


These independent sites offer the cheapest booking so most people like to use these sites while booking hotels. Hotels however, have started reporting inconsistencies with the timing and invoicing from tripadvisor/ Already is not favoured by many hotels as they allow for what is effectively a free cancellation up until the last minute.



But hotels have reported that with tripadvisor there are random invoiced amounts appearing on statements and credit cards which hotels are struggling to reconcile against individual bookings. There is also a generic pushback by hotels against the big players. Margins have been squeezed enormously by the likes of Expedia and hotels are now trying to take control.



Italy’s antitrust authority has fined TripAdvisor 500,000 Euros ($600,000) following complaints of improper business practices lodged by a national hoteliers’ association and a consumer protection agency for failing to control false reviews in 2014. Indeed the site continues to have negative comments and false reviews on its site every month. So travellers will have to stop depending solely on TripAdvisor and other booking sites which may be misleading many and keeping them away from great properties just because they ranked fairly or badly on TripAdvisor!

Tags: ,

2 Responses to Don’t follow TripAdvisor wearing a blindfold

  1. I have lived abroad for 18 years, and in 107 countries, and never use tripadvisor, or many reasons. But here is a fun story, I have a friend from Canada who got a job a TripAdvisor doing SEO, he was paid 200K plus. Well, after a couple of years, he quit, got a job in Thailand working for 5 hotels, more or less using his inside knowledge to lobby. More or less to game the whole system of TripAdvisor for a large salary. Personally, I think it a little insane to think that a person who goes on a 2 week vacation one time per year knows anything about how to evaluate a Hotel. Sort of like person having one date, now saying this person is good enough to marry. We get many comments on HoboTraveler COM and a good comment seldom is worded even slightly as clean, concise, as TripAdvisor reviews, the reek of gaming. Thank you, Andy Lee Graham

  2. Mary Lou says:

    I was disappointed when Trip advisor started reserving hotel rooms..
    I’m afraid they now don’t have honest, “for no reason” recommendations.
    They,Trip Advisor,is trying to make a profit on traveler’s experience.
    I have been a trip advisor and loved the idea that I was telling other travelers the true facts about a property.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

arrow2Follow TTW
facebook-logo  twitter-logo  LinkedIn_logo  stumbleupon-logo   rss_logo 
ttw_blogger_logo  ttw_blogger_logo  ttw_blogger_logo


  • 01 AIME 2018 BB
  • 02 WTM Latin America 2018
  • 03 EMITT 2018
  • 04 AIME-2018 small
  • 05 itb-china 2018
  • 06 Central & Eastern Europe 2018
  • 06 imtm 2018
  • 06 TTF-2018
  • 07 balttour 2018
  • 07 ibtm arabia 2018
  • 08 mice-arabia 18
  • 09 The hotel shows audiarabia 18
  • 10 hotelfair 2018
  • 10 miceforum 18
  • 11 Digital Travel 2018
  • 30 PATA


Get our toolbar!
Review on