New York Faces Federal Scrutiny Over CDL Violations Threatening Interstate Travel and Road Safety, Here is What You Need to Know

Published on December 14, 2025

New York is facing federal scrutiny after an alarming audit exposed serious violations in its commercial driver’s license (CDL) program. The U.S. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) found that New York’s Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) has been issuing CDLs to foreign drivers in direct violation of federal regulations. This issue threatens road safety, as unqualified drivers could be operating commercial vehicles across the state. With New York being a critical hub for interstate travel, the potential risks extend far beyond the state’s borders. Ensuring that only qualified drivers are on the road is essential to maintaining safe travel for all. As New York navigates this challenge, the impact on road safety and interstate travel could be profound, especially for those relying on commercial transport for both goods and tourism. Immediate action is needed to resolve the violations and restore trust in the state’s CDL program.

Major Findings of the FMCSA Audit

The audit focused on non-domiciled CDLs, which are issued to foreign drivers who are not permanent U.S. residents. Of the 200 records sampled, 107 were found to have been issued in violation of federal law, making the failure rate alarmingly high at over 53%. This discovery has brought to light several key failures within the system. For instance, New York’s DMV systems were programmed to automatically issue 8-year licenses to foreign drivers, regardless of when their lawful presence in the U.S. expired. This means that licenses were granted without verifying whether the individuals holding them were legally allowed to remain in the country.

In addition to this, the DMV was found to have issued commercial licenses to foreign drivers without providing any evidence that their lawful presence in the U.S. had been properly verified. The audit also revealed instances where expired lawful presence documents were used to issue commercial licenses. This blatant disregard for federal regulations is seen as a gross violation, compromising the integrity of New York’s CDL system.

Threats to Road Safety and Interstate Travel

The issuance of non-compliant CDLs poses significant risks to road safety, as commercial drivers are responsible for the safe transport of goods and passengers across state lines. With New York being a major hub for both domestic and international travel, the consequences of allowing unqualified drivers on the road could be far-reaching. From chartered buses to interstate freight, New York’s transportation system plays a vital role in keeping travel and trade flowing smoothly across the U.S.

The FMCSA has called for immediate action from New York to rectify these violations. U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy emphasized that if the state fails to revoke the illegally issued licenses, it could face severe financial penalties, including the withholding of approximately $73 million in federal highway funding. This decision would have a ripple effect on the state’s road infrastructure, potentially slowing down critical maintenance and construction projects that are vital to interstate travel.

Immediate Federal Action and Potential Consequences

In response to the audit, the FMCSA has ordered New York to pause the issuance of all non-domiciled CDLs and commercial learner’s permits (CLPs). The state has been given 30 days to take corrective action, including conducting a thorough internal audit to identify all non-compliant licenses and revoke any that are found to be issued illegally. Failure to comply with these measures could result in the complete decertification of New York’s CDL program, further disrupting road safety and interstate travel across the state.

The state’s failure to enforce proper CDL regulations also poses a direct threat to the tourism industry, as commercial drivers play a crucial role in transporting visitors to key destinations. From guided tours to airport shuttle services, the integrity of the CDL program is paramount to ensuring that tourists can safely navigate the state’s roads. If the state does not act swiftly, it risks alienating both domestic and international visitors who rely on safe and reliable transportation options while traveling.

Protecting Road Safety and Restoring Trust in New York’s CDL Program

To restore public confidence in New York’s CDL program and protect road safety, the state must act decisively. By revoking all illegally issued licenses and implementing stricter measures for verifying a driver’s legal status, New York can begin to repair the damage caused by this audit. It is imperative that the state work closely with federal authorities to ensure that all commercial drivers are properly vetted and qualified to operate vehicles on public roads.

Interstate travel and road safety are inextricably linked to the integrity of New York’s CDL program. As one of the busiest states for both tourism and commerce, New York cannot afford to compromise on these issues. The state’s leadership must prioritize compliance with federal regulations and take immediate action to address the violations uncovered by the FMCSA audit. By doing so, New York can ensure the safety of its residents, visitors and commercial drivers, safeguarding the future of road travel across the U.S.

Conclusion: A Critical Moment for New York’s Transportation System

As New York faces increased scrutiny over its CDL practices, the state must act swiftly to rectify these violations and ensure compliance with federal road safety regulations. With significant consequences for interstate travel, tourism and public safety, the pressure is on state officials to implement reforms and restore confidence in New York’s transportation system. The stakes are high and timely action will be key to maintaining the safety and integrity of U.S. roads.